Pakistan easeful Bin Laden? Prove it

Pakistan easeful Bin Laden? Prove it

66
0
SHARE


.cnn_html_media_utility::before{color:red;content:’>>’;font-size:9px;line-height:12px;padding-right:1px}
.cnnstrylccimg640{margin:0 27px 14px 0}
.captionText{filter:alpha(opacity=100);opacity:1}
.cnn_html_slideshow_media_caption a,.cnn_html_slideshow_media_caption a:visited,.cnn_html_slideshow_media_caption a:link,.captionText a,.captionText a:visited,.captiontext a:link{color:outline:medium none}
.cnnVerticalGalleryPhoto{margin:0 auto;padding-right:68px;width:270px}
]]>

Vice President Joe Biden, left, President Barack Obama, and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, second from right, watch a goal to constraint Osama bin Laden from a Situation Room in a White House on May 1, 2011. Click by to see reactions from around a universe following a genocide of a al Qaeda leader.Vice President Joe Biden, left, President Barack Obama, and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, second from right, watch a goal to constraint Osama bin Laden from a Situation Room in a White House on May 1, 2011. Click by to see reactions from around a universe following a genocide of a al Qaeda leader.

President Obama edits his remarks in a Oval Office before to creation a televised matter announcing bin Laden's death.President Obama edits his remarks in a Oval Office before to creation a televised matter announcing bin Laden’s death.

Servicemen hearten from a flare post as thousands of people accumulate during Ground Zero in New York City.Servicemen hearten from a flare post as thousands of people accumulate during Ground Zero in New York City.

Crowds applaud with NYPD officers in New York's Times Square early on May 2, 2011, after a genocide of Osama bin Laden.Crowds applaud with NYPD officers in New York’s Times Square early on May 2, 2011, after a genocide of Osama bin Laden.

Revelers accumulate during a blockade on a north side of a White House.Revelers accumulate during a blockade on a north side of a White House.

Afghans watch radio coverage in Kabul announcing a murdering of bin Laden.Afghans watch radio coverage in Kabul announcing a murdering of bin Laden.

U.S. Marines watch a proclamation of bin Laden's genocide during Camp Dwyer in Helmand Province, Afghanistan.U.S. Marines watch a proclamation of bin Laden’s genocide during Camp Dwyer in Helmand Province, Afghanistan.

Times Square is filled shortly after a proclamation of bin Laden's death.Times Square is filled shortly after a proclamation of bin Laden’s death.

Students accumulate to applaud during a blockade on a north side of a White House.Students accumulate to applaud during a blockade on a north side of a White House.

A bystander looks during journal headlines in front of a Newseum in Washington.A bystander looks during journal headlines in front of a Newseum in Washington.

Danielle LeMack, left, Carie LeMack and Christie Coombs, who mislaid kin on 9/11, postponement during a rite to respect a victims on May 2, 2011, during a Garden of Remembrance in Boston.Danielle LeMack, left, Carie LeMack and Christie Coombs, who mislaid kin on 9/11, postponement during a rite to respect a victims on May 2, 2011, during a Garden of Remembrance in Boston.

A caller photographs a blockade unaware a pile-up site of Flight 93 in Shanksville, Pennsylvania, on May 2, 2011.A caller photographs a blockade unaware a pile-up site of Flight 93 in Shanksville, Pennsylvania, on May 2, 2011.

Pakistani media and residents accumulate outward a bin Laden hideout on May 3, 2011.Pakistani media and residents accumulate outward a bin Laden hideout on May 3, 2011.


1


2


3


4


5


6


7


8


9


10


11


12


13

Editor’s note: Peter Bergen is CNN’s inhabitant confidence analyst, a executive during a New America Foundation and a author of “Manhunt: The Ten-Year Search for bin Laden — From 9/11 to Abbottabad.”

(CNN) — The New York Times repository is using a bombshell story alleging that a Pakistanis knew all along that Osama bin Laden was vital for years in his longtime stealing place in a northern Pakistan city of Abbottabad, where he was killed by a U.S. Navy SEAL group on May 2, 2011.

The Times story, patrician “What Pakistan Knew About bin Laden,” will lift weight: It was created by Carlotta Gall, a vanguard of a correspondents who have lonesome Afghanistan and Pakistan given that fatal day in 2001, when al Qaeda’s 4 hijacked planes crashed by America’s gentle clarity that immeasurable oceans insulated it from a enemies.

Peter Bergen during coverage of CNN's Anderson Cooper 360 on plcae in Afghanistan

At good personal risk Gall has sanctioned lonesome a fight in Afghanistan for a past 12 years. Indeed, we initial met her during a polite fight in Afghanistan during a mid-1990s when she was an assist worker, and we have met her many times since. we speedy her (along with, I’m sure, many others) to write a book about her stating in Afghanistan, as no Western contributor has some-more to contend about what has transpired there given a tumble of a Taliban.

The bin Laden story in a New York Times repository is an remove from Gall’s stirring book, “The Wrong Enemy: America in Afghanistan, 2001-2014.”

Gall creates dual startling claims in her Times repository piece.

The initial claim: An unnamed Pakistani central told her, formed on what he had in spin listened from an unnamed comparison U.S. central that “the United States had approach justification that a ISI chief, Lt. Gen. Ahmed Shuja Pasha, knew of bin Laden’s participation in Abbottabad.” ISI is Pakistan’s absolute troops comprehension agency.

The second claim: “The ISI indeed ran a special table reserved to hoop bin Laden. It was operated independently, led by an officer who done his possess decisions and did not news to a superior. He rubbed usually one person: bin Laden…the tip troops bosses knew about it, we was told.”

It is, of course, tough to infer negatives, though carrying spent around a year stating intensively on a hunt for al Qaeda’s personality for my 2012 book “Manhunt: The Ten-Year Search for bin Laden From 9/11 to Abbottabad,” we am assured that there is no justification that anyone in a Pakistani government, troops or comprehension agencies intentionally easeful bin Laden.


Gates on OBL Death: There were no cheers


Admiral: Destroy Osama bin Laden photos


Admiral: Destroy Osama bin Laden photos

How did we arrive during this conclusion?

On 3 stating trips to Pakistan we spoke to comparison officials in Pakistan’s troops and comprehension service. They all denied that they had personally harbored bin Laden. OK, we are thinking: “But they would contend that, wouldn’t they?”

Well, what about a dozens of officials we spoke to in a U.S. comprehension community, Pentagon, State Department and a White House who also told me versions of “the Pakistanis had no thought that bin Laden was stealing in Abbottabad”?

During a march of stating for my book we spoke on a record to, among others, John Brennan, now a CIA executive and afterwards President Obama’s tip counterterrorism adviser; afterwards CIA Director Leon Panetta and his arch of staff, Jeremy Bash; afterwards Secretary of State Hillary Clinton; afterwards Chairman of a Joint Chiefs, Adm. Mike Mullen; afterwards Vice Chairman of a Joint Chiefs, Gen. James Cartwright; afterwards executive of a National Counterterrorism Center, Michael Leiter; afterwards comparison executive for counterterrorism during a National Security Council, Nick Rasmussen; afterwards conduct of process during a Pentagon, Michele Flournoy; Michael Vickers, who was afterwards a municipal supervisor of Special Operations during a Pentagon; Tony Blinken, who is now a emissary inhabitant confidence adviser; and Denis McDonough, who hold that position before Blinken.

These officials have collectively spent many decades operative to destroy al Qaeda, and many are deeply questionable of Pakistan for a stability support for elements of a Taliban. But all of them told me in one form or another that Pakistani officials had no idea that bin Laden was vital in Abbottabad.

Indeed, an early discuss between comparison inhabitant confidence officials during a White House, once CIA comprehension determined that bin Laden could be stealing in Abbottabad, was either to mountain a corner U.S.-Pakistani raid on bin Laden’s suspected hideout.

This devise was deserted since a officials were endangered that such a corner operation carried a risk that word would trickle out about a bin Laden intelligence. This discuss would have been indecisive if a Pakistanis already knew bin Laden was vital in Abbottabad.

And, by a way, if a U.S. supervision had any justification that a Pakistanis were intentionally sheltering bin Laden, as Gall claims, because cover this up?

In 2011, a attribute between a United States and Pakistan was at a lowest point ever. Early that year a CIA executive killed dual Pakistanis in extended illumination in a city of Lahore, and both countries were trade accusations about any other’s perfidy. The tragedy was compounded by a fact that a CIA worker module in Pakistan was afterwards during a height, that was deeply unpopular among Pakistanis. What did U.S. officials have to remove by observant that bin Laden was being stable by a Pakistanis if it were true?

The fact is that a comparison Pakistani officials Gall alleges were harboring bin Laden were definitely astounded that al Qaeda’s personality was vital in Abbottabad. Based on a doubtful reactions of tip Pakistani officials to a events on a night that bin Laden was killed, it was apparent to U.S. Ambassador to Pakistan Cameron Munter and to U.S. officials monitoring communications in Pakistan that a Pakistanis had not had a idea about bin Laden’s participation there.

Finally, in a march of stating my book we detected that bin Laden was even stealing from some of a people vital in his possess compound; forget about vouchsafing officials in a Pakistani supervision in on a secret. One of a wives of a bodyguards safeguarding bin Laden didn’t know that a high foreigner stealing on a devalue was al Qaeda’s leader.

In integrity to Gall, we have listened from 4 stream and former U.S. comprehension and troops officials that some of a thousands of papers that U.S. Navy SEALs picked adult during bin Laden’s Abbottabad devalue that haven’t been publicly expelled could indicate to some kind of central Pakistani collusion.

If that is a case, a Obama White House should recover any papers that are applicable so that a American open can be a decider if one of a allies was intentionally harboring bin Laden all along. So distant there is no justification that that is a case.

Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion.

Join us on Facebook/CNNOpinion.



Article source: http://www.cnn.com/2014/03/21/opinion/bergen-bin-laden-new-york-times/